By Rose O. Sherman, EdD, RN, NEA-BC, FAAN
We are entering the time when organizations begin hiring for their nurse residency programs. I am a firm believer that nurse managers need to be involved in the selection process, as the manager-nurse relationship is critically important.
Transitioning from a student to a professional nurse is a high-stakes period, and as we have discussed in these blogs, the first year is where we lose the most talent. Retention begins at the point of interview. The interview process allows the manager to assess a candidate’s self-awareness and their expectations of the transition before they ever step into the unit. It also gives nurse managers an opportunity to establish their own expectations of candidates. Below are some questions you may want to add to those you already ask in your interviews.
In your clinical rotations, what was the most significant gap you noticed between what you learned in the classroom and how care was actually delivered?
This tests their observation skills and their ability to handle the “reality shock” of a fast-paced environment. It also helps you determine how situationally aware they are about the gaps in expectations they will experience when they enter practice.
Can you describe a time you felt overwhelmed during a clinical shift? How did you prioritize your next steps?
Critical for assessing their budding clinical judgment and whether they “freeze” or “focus” under pressure.
What qualities are you looking for in a preceptor to help you feel successful in your first six months?
This helps the manager determine whether they have a compatible preceptor on staff or whether the candidate’s learning style aligns with the unit’s resources.
Tell me about a time you realized you were “in over your head” with a patient during a clinical experience. Who did you go to and how did you approach them?
This is a safety-critical question. You are looking for a candidate who isn’t afraid to admit they don’t know something. Understanding the importance of team backup is critical in new graduate transitions.
We all have blind spots and superpowers. What is the superpower that you would bring to our team? Based on your clinical evaluations, what is one area where you know you will need extra support from us during orientation?
This measures self-awareness. A candidate who says “I’m good at everything” is often a higher risk than one who knows they struggle with, for example, time management or starting IVs.
What are your expectations about support from me as your manager?
Many new graduates report a lack of support from their managers, and recent data indicate that Generation Z needs much more face-to-face interaction with leaders. Understanding what support looks like through the eyes of the new graduate is critical to a successful transition.
Describe a situation where you had a disagreement with a peer or instructor. How was it resolved?
Nurse leaders spend a great deal of their time managing staff conflicts. Asking this question helps identify the new graduate’s experience with conflict management and whether they have the emotional intelligence to handle the lateral violence or friction that can sometimes occur in high-stress units.
How do you plan to manage the transition from being a student to working 12-hour shifts and not having semester breaks?
This touches on their resilience and “staying power.” You want to see whether they have considered the ongoing physical and mental stamina required for the role.
Hospitals are open 24/7. What are your expectations about what shifts you will work and how often you will work weekends?
New graduates today rank scheduling flexibility among their top three priorities, yet managers must staff their units 24/7. This question opens the door to a conversation about what a new graduate can reasonably expect from you as a manager in terms of their schedule.
If you find yourself struggling three months into the job, what is the best way for me, as your manager, to support you?
This sets the stage for the “Inverted Pyramid” leadership style right from the start—letting them know you are there to coach, not just supervise.
Interviews should be a two-way street. These questions aren’t just for the manager to vet the nurse; they signal to the New Grad that this unit and you, as its manager, value transparency, safety, and mentorship.
© emergingrnleader.com 2026
To effectively lead through these challenges and others, nurse leaders need new tools and strategies. Let me help you as I have helped hundreds of organizations over the past five years. Book a workshop or keynote for your team by contacting me at roseosherman@outlook.com
Brand New For 2026 and Already Receiving Rave Reviews – Staying Power Building a Culture of Retention in the New World of Work
Brand New for 2026 and Already Popular – The Inverted Pyramid: Leading Teams of Novice Nurses The Inverted Pyramid WS Information Sheet
Our Most Popular Right Now –The New World of Work Workshop
A Leader Favorite – Building Bridges Not Walls: Leading Multigenerational Work Teams – Click Here for More Information Building Bridges Not Walls
A Must-Read Book in 2026 – Click Here to Buy
LinkedIn
Instagram