• Home
  • About the Author
  • Books
  • Workshops and Keynotes
  • Contact Us

Emerging Nurse Leader

A leadership development blog

The Conundrum with Nurse Leader Span of Control

September 8, 2025 by rose

By Rose O. Sherman, EdD, RN, NEA-BC, FAAN

Nurse leaders often ask me how their span of control compares to other industries. I usually answer that it is not even comparable – nurse leaders have so many more staff who directly report to them.

I was reminded of this when I read an article recently in The Wall Street Journal titled, “Your Boss Doesn’t Have Time to Talk to You.” Managers in corporate America interviewed for this article complained about the growth in their span of control, which has increased from an average of 5 in 2017 to 12-20 today. Few nurse managers today have that luxury; yet, this article noted how challenging it is for managers to spend time developing employees as their span of control grows. One manager noted how managers no longer ask about personal parts of their employees’ lives because they have no time for these conversations, so much for establishing connections with your staff.

Having spent more than four decades in nursing leadership, I now have a lot of historical context. I reflect on the factors and events that have led us to where we are today. I think back to my own experience as a new graduate on a 60 Bed Medical Unit with a head nurse (then the term for nurse manager) who probably supervised at least 50 staff and never appeared frazzled. But context is everything, and here are some key differences between then (the late 1970s) and now:

  • I was one of two new graduates hired during the year – the majority of nurses on this medical unit had 10+ years of experience, and turnover was extremely low. Fast forward to today, where the average Medical-Surgical unit can have up to 70% of nurses in their first three years of practice.
  • The majority of nurses in the US worked in hospitals (over 80%), and most were diploma-educated and did not return to further their education.
  • The average manager in the 1970s had been a nurse for decades and had longevity in their roles. They were backed up by a core team of expert nurses working with them. They spent the bulk of their time on staffing, scheduling, and supply management. There were NO KPIs they were personally held accountable for, and many did not even manage their own budgets.
  • Patient length of stay was extended, averaging seven days on our unit. Patient acuity outside of ICUs was low, as were ADTs. Most patients who were in ICUs in the 1970s would be on medical-surgical units. Most patients hospitalized on medical-surgical units in the 1970s would be managed as outpatients today.
  • We had no electronic medical records; all documentation was entered manually. It was like pulling teeth to get staff to document, even then.
  • Patient and family expectations were far lower than they are today.
  • Many management theorists at the time believed that spans of control could be much higher when professionals were being supervised.

It was against this backdrop that managers often supervised 50+ nursing staff. This worked for a period of time because units were stable, staffing was stable, expectations were lower, and turnover was rare. It no longer works because the context of the healthcare environment has changed in ways that would have been unimaginable in the 1970s.

We know that today nurse managers’ span of control is closely linked to retention rates among early-tenure nurses, according to research from the American Organization for Nursing Leadership and Laudio. There is a clear link between the number of direct reports a nurse manager is responsible for and turnover rates among early-tenure nurses. On average, managers with 90 or more direct reports saw turnover rates as high as 40%. When nurse managers led teams of 30, turnover among new nurses averaged 27%. A nurse manager’s ability to conduct check-ins with new hires is closely tied to first-year retention. Managers who conducted check-ins after a new hire’s first 30 or 45 days saw a 6-percentage point increase in first-year retention on average. Six- or nine-month check-ins improved first-year retention by 10 percentage points.

So, where do we go from here? We are in a conundrum where we know what the evidence shows us, but can’t act on it. Finances are tight for the foreseeable future, making it infeasible to add new layers of management in many organizations right now. The situation has become even more complicated because many nurse managers are converting full-time FTEs into part-time positions to meet staff needs. When they do this, they add to their own span of control, complicating an already challenging situation.

When you know you can’t add additional leader FTE, the next logical step is to look at the top five activities nurse managers spend their time on in your organization (this differs widely across organizations). As you look at these activities, including meeting attendance, decide whether 1. Do they need to be done at all?  2. Do they need to be done by the nurse manager? 3. Can any of the activities be significantly streamlined (pulling unit data comes to mind)?

The goal should be to be relentless in creating white space in the calendars of nurse managers you already have so they can do more rounding, coaching, and mentoring. While this won’t solve all of the problems with large spans of control, it is the place to start during this challenging time.

© emergingrnleader.com 2025

Our Most Popular Right Now   The New World of Work Workshop

Two Brand New Workshops for Your Team in 2025

*** Trending – Building Bridges Not Walls: Leading Multigenerational Work Teams – Click Here for More Information   Building Bridges Not Walls

Nurse and Nurse Leader Work-Life Balance and Well-Being: Nursing Leadership Strategies for Success – Click Here for More Information WorkLife Balance and Wellbeing WS

New Book – Click Here to Buy

Filed Under: Conflict Management, Leading Others, The Business of Healthcare

Sign Up For Blogs!

Get the latest blog posts sent directly to your email. Don't miss a post!

 

Popular Posts

  • A Blog for Nursing Leadership Skills & Career Strategies
  • iStock_000015892112XSmall 5 Ways to Promote Professional Accountability in Nursing
  • Servant Leadership in Nursing
  • Becoming a Transformational Nurse Leader

Recent Posts

  • FMLA in Nursing: When Employee Rights and Staffing Realities Collide
  • You Bought Microsoft Copilot: Did Anyone Teach Nurse Managers How to Use It?
  • Ten Things Nurse Managers Wish Their CNOs Knew But Some Don’t
  • The Inverted Pyramid – Workshop December 8th, 2026
  • Calculating the ROI of Meetings You Attend: The Five Question Audit

Categories

  • Career Tips
  • Communication
  • Conflict Management
  • Leading Others
  • The Business of Healthcare
  • The Charge Nurse Role
  • The Future of Healthcare
  • The Leader Within

    Translate to:

    Powered by Google Translate.

Search

Books

The Nurse Leader Coach: Become The Boss No One Wants To Leave
The Nuts and Bolts of Nursing Leadership: Your Toolkit for Success

© Copyright 2012 Emerging RN Leader · All Rights Reserved

LinkedIn LinkedIn Instagram Instagram
grab this