By Rose O. Sherman, EdD, RN, NEA-BC, FAAN
Failure is hard for many reasons, not the least of which is that most of us focus on our highlight reels and not what hasn’t worked. I was reminded of this recently as I coached an executive nurse fellow who has struggled with her research project (a requirement to complete the fellowship program). Sobbing, she told me the following story:
I feel like a total failure. I chose a project that I am passionate about and would make a significant contribution to my healthcare setting. I knew I had a short timeline, but I was confident I could finish the study in the timeframe we were given. If I had done this five or six years ago, the outcome might have looked different. My team and I brainstormed and believed we had covered all the bases. We were sure the outcomes would be excellent. To my surprise, the participation and dropout rates were disappointing. My final number is so low that any findings will not be generalizable to a larger population, and I can’t imagine too many journals will be interested in publishing it. I am so ashamed that I can’t even talk about it with my fellowship cohort.
As someone who has done quite a bit of research in her life, her story is not unusual. Most research takes twice as long to complete as you initially project and usually involves many iterations. I had been down this road many times with doctoral students working on their dissertations. Her challenge was that she lacked the time to make the necessary pivots to implement the required changes. We discussed what she learned and would do differently in the future, but the conversation was tough for her. Ultimately, I know that this experience will be formative for this young leader, but she is too close to the situation to see it that way right now.
Failure is an inevitable part of learning. If you don’t fail, you don’t learn. If you don’t learn, you’ll never change. I suggested she put a sticky on her computer to remind her of this:
F – first
A – attempt
I – in
L – learning
When I spoke with her, I realized that we don’t prepare our leaders for the possibility of failure nor do we talk about it can be transformative. Yet, every successful nurse leader has had the experience of designing an intervention that did not work, not being selected for a coveted position, failing to achieve a goal, making a bad judgment call, or possibly being fired or asked to step down from a position. I was fortunate in my early career to have some leader mentors that I could confide in without any fear of being judged. I worked with one Chief Nursing Officer who was remarkable in her ability to identify the upside of any leadership mistake that I made.
While failure is inevitable we don’t publicly discuss it. Yet, it is part of the leadership experience. We celebrate our successes and most of our nursing journal articles focus on what is working in organizations. I edited a leadership journal for a decade and rarely received articles on initiatives that did not worked. If you never fail, you probably are not taking risks that will lead to your personal growth or innovation in your organization. This is especially true in the current environment. Reflection is important after failure to grow and learn from the experience. Too often, leaders get into the blame game when there is a failure rather than admit their role in what happened. Some key questions to ask include:
- What happened and why?
- What key signs did I miss leading up to the failure?
- What were the consequences of what happened here?
- What did I learn as a leader from this situation?
- How will I apply any lessons learned in the future?
Our failures can be some of our best teachers if we pay attention and learn from them. Fredrich Nietzsche once observed that “that which does not kill us makes us stronger”. This is wise advice for leaders as they learn and grow from both their successes and failures.
© emergingrnleader.com 2025
Our Most Popular Right Now The New World of Work Workshop
Two Brand New Workshops for Your Team in 2025
*** Trending – Building Bridges Not Walls: Leading Multigenerational Work Teams – Click Here for More Information Building Bridges Not Walls
Nurse and Nurse Leader Work-Life Balance and Well-Being: Nursing Leadership Strategies for Success – Click Here for More Information WorkLife Balance and Wellbeing WS
New Book – Click Here to Buy


LinkedIn
Instagram