By Rose O. Sherman, EdD, RN, NEA-BC, FAAN
In novice-nurse-dense environments, the nurse preceptor role is a critical organizational asset for successful new-graduate transition. Preceptor burnout is a growing concern, especially in light of recent Laudio data, which indicates that nurse preceptors who spend more than 20% of their scheduled hours in the role are at higher risk for burnout.
So whenever I have the opportunity to speak with a group of experienced nurse preceptors, I use it to learn more about their experiences. Last week, I spent time with nurse preceptors at the University of Rochester Medical Center. I was there for their graduation from a one-year preceptor academy, which is a true exemplar of preceptor development and coaching. I asked them what they wanted nurse leaders to know about their role. Five clear themes emerged from our discussion:
1. Precepting is a challenging role, and it doubles the preceptor’s cognitive load.
Too often, staffing grids or assignment models treat a preceptor-preceptee pair as two productive nurses or assign them heavier patient loads, assuming preceptors can manage multiple acute admissions while teaching the new nurse. Precepting actually doubles cognitive load. The preceptor simultaneously assesses the patient, thinks aloud, observes every step the novice takes, anticipates errors, and teaches clinical judgment in real time. Nurse leaders should design assignments that allow time for teaching. Assigning a preceptor a maximum-acuity or complex workload while training a new graduate is a recipe for rapid burnout.
2. Preceptor fatigue is real, and they need a break from their preceptee.
A real ah-ha moment for me in our discussion came when preceptor Janine Miller talked about fatigue while precepting. A 12-hour shift on a busy unit is physically and mentally demanding for any nurse, but for a preceptor, it is 720 minutes of continuous performance, hyper-vigilance, and constant narration. For many preceptors, particularly introverts who naturally recharge through solitude and quiet, being tethered to an orientee every single minute is emotionally depleting. By midday, decision fatigue sets in. Expecting a preceptor to spend their 30-minute meal break answering more questions, debriefing, or maintaining social energy robs them of their only opportunity to reset. They want leaders to support unit norms that separate preceptor and orientee breaks. Ensure the charge nurse or a partner covers the orientee during meal times, giving the preceptor permission to step off the floor, disconnect in silence, and genuinely recharge for the second half of the shift.
3. Leaders and preceptors need to be on the same page about preceptee performance.
Preceptors take immense pride in bringing new colleagues along, but they also feel deeply accountable for patient safety. Create formal pathways for targeted remedial support or orientation extensions rather than defaulting to hard timelines about when certain tasks should be completed. Preceptors try to build psychological safety for novices, but managers sometimes undermine it. Preceptors understand that managers cannot always share performance plans for new graduates, but they should have regular opportunities to discuss new graduate performance.
4. Don’t default to using the same preceptors all the time.
When units face continuous turnover and rolling residency cohorts, managers often default to the same small, reliable core of senior nurses. Continuous precepting across consecutive cohorts drains clinical passion. Without intentional rest cycles where experienced nurses can simply care for their own patients without teaching, your best clinicians will eventually step down from the role or leave the unit. Track precepting hours systematically. Normalize scheduled off-cycles so senior staff have dedicated stretches of independent practice to refresh before taking on another orientee.
5. Recognize the work of preceptors.
Preceptors want their managers to see the invisible emotional labor involved: managing novice anxiety, navigating generational communication differences, having hard feedback conversations, and fostering psychological safety. Close the feedback loop. Check in specifically about how the teaching relationship is progressing, publicly credit preceptors when orientees launch successfully, and actively advocate for their professional growth and development.
Under pressure, leaders can easily view preceptorship through an operational lens as an orientation checklist to complete or a staffing pipeline to fill. But in reality, your preceptors are the cultural and clinical anchor of your unit. Every patient safety standard upheld, every crisis calmly navigated, and every novice nurse who chooses to stay past year one rests on the quality of that preceptor relationship.
When nurse managers actively protect their preceptors by defending their workloads, respecting their need for shift-level mental downtime, and honoring their clinical assessments, the return on investment is unmistakable. Precepting is high-stakes emotional and clinical labor. When you invest in safeguarding your preceptors’ energy and well-being, you aren’t just making their 12-hour shifts more sustainable; you are building a resilient, high-performing culture that outlasts every staffing challenge.
© emergingrnleader.com 2026
Great for New Ideas Around Staff Retention – Staying Power: Building a Culture of Retention in the New World of Work
Brand New for 2026 and Already Receiving Rave Reviews – The Inverted Pyramid: Leading Teams of Novice Nurses The Inverted Pyramid WS Information Sheet
Always Popular –The New World of Work Workshop
A Leader Favorite – Building Bridges Not Walls: Leading Multigenerational Work Teams – Click Here for More Information Building Bridges Not Walls
A Must-Read Book in 2026 – Click Here to Buy
LinkedIn
Instagram